You are currently browsing the tag archive for the ‘linear coincidence’ tag.

It’s been an awfully long time since I’ve posted anything; time to finally break the silence.

This problem appeared elsewhere on the internet some months ago; some of you may have already seen it. I don’t want to say right away where I saw it, because there was some commentary which included some rough hints which I don’t want to give, but I’ll be sure to give credit when the solution is published. I’ll bet some of you will be able to find a solution, and will agree it’s quite cute. Here it is:

Given integers m, n \geq 1, show that it is possible to construct a set of m + n points in the plane, let’s say x_1, \ldots, x_m, y_1, \ldots, y_n, so that no three points of the set are collinear, and for which there exist points z_1, z_2, \ldots, z_{m+n-1}, all lying on a straight line, and arranged so that on the line between any x_i and any y_j, some z_k lies between them.

So no x_i can “see” any y_j, because there’s always some z_k blocking the view. As the proposer observed, the problem would be easy if we had m n z‘s to play with, one for each pair (x_i, y_j). But here there are only m+ n-1 z‘s, so some of them will have to do more than their fair share, blocking the view between quite a few (x, y)-pairs simultaneously. Thus, you have to arrange the x‘s and y‘s so that a lot of the lines between them will be coincident at a point z, and subject to the constraint I italicized above.

Please submit solutions to topological[dot]musings[At]gmail[dot]com by Friday, July 17, 11:59 pm (UTC); do not submit solutions in Comments. Everyone with a correct solution will be inducted into our Hall of Fame! We look forward to your response.

Our other blog

Visitors to this blog

Blog Stats

  • 357,711 hits

Wikio Ranking

Wikio - Top Blogs - Sciences

Current Online Readers

Recent Comments

Convictions ·… on Continued fraction for e
John Favors on Solution to POW-13: Highly…
Wayne J. Mann on Solution to POW-12: A graph co…
erneststephen on The 54th Carnival of Math…
anhtraisg on p^q + q^p is prime
prof dr drd horia or… on My first post
prof drd horia orasa… on My first post
prof dr mircea orasa… on Inequality with log
notedscholar on Self-referential Paradoxes, In…
prof dr mircea orasa… on Inequality with log
prof dr mircea orasa… on Inequality with log
prof dr mircea orasa… on 2010 in review
kenji on Basic category theory, I
prof dr mircea orasa… on Solution to POW-10: Another ha…
prof drd horia orasa… on Continued fraction for e


July 2021